Newer GPUs:
Use 12V-2×6 / 12VHPWR connectors with power-sense signaling
Have much higher transient (spike) loads
Can draw large bursts of current in microseconds
Even if average power looks acceptable, the PSU must handle short-duration spikes without voltage sag.
Does PSU quality matter or just wattage?
Both matter.
A good PSU should be:
ATX 3.0 / PCIe Gen5 compliant for 40- and 50-series GPUs
From a reputable brand
Equipped with a native 12V-2×6 cable (not adapters when possible)
An 850W low-quality unit can perform worse than a 750W high-quality one.